Welcome to Baking by Peyton’s custom cake ordering page!

Ready to create your perfect cake? Take a look at the options below for cake sizes, flavors, and more. Once you’ve chosen your details, simply fill out the order form at the bottom of the page, and I’ll bring your vision to life

Step 1: Select Your Cake Size

Please note that the prices listed are base prices and do not include custom decorations, which may increase the final cost depending on the complexity of your design.

Step Two: Select Your Flavors

Select Your Cake Flavor

Vanilla
Chocolate
Funfetti
Red Velvet
Lemon
Oreo
Chocolate Chip
Gluten Free: Chocolate, Vanilla, Red Velvet
Available for an additional charge of $10.
Vegan: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Chocolate Chip, Lemon
Available for an additional charge of $10.
Please Note: Our gluten-free and vegan cakes are prepared in the same kitchen as cakes containing gluten and animal products. While we take great care to prevent cross-contamination, it is still possible.
Select Your Buttercream Flavor

Famous Vanilla
Chocolate
Cream Cheese
Oreo
Salted Caramel
Peanut Butter
Lemon
Vegan: Vanilla or Chocolate
Select Your Filling Flavor

Classic Buttercream
Chocolate Fudge
Chocolate Hazelnut
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
White Chocolate Oreo Fudge
Salted Caramel
Raspberry Compote
Peanut Butter Cup
Lemon Curd
Signature Cake Flavors, Extra

Pastel Rainbow Layered $20 / Tier
Creme Brulee$20/Tier- graham cracker crusted vanilla bean cake, classic custard filling, vanilla buttercream
Lemon Bar $20/Tier - shortbread crusted lemon cake, lemon curd filling, vanilla buttercream
Cannoli $20/Tier - cinnamon cake, traditional cannoli filling, vanilla buttercream
Ultimate S’mores $20/Tier - graham cracker crusted dark chocolate cake. toasted marshmallow filling, chocolate ganache, chocolate buttercream

Next Steps To Order Your Custom Cake:

Step 1: Submit Your Order Form

Please fill out the order form below with as much detail as possible to help me create your invoice. Be sure to include everything you want for your cake. If you have inspiration photos, email them to me separately. Keep in mind that Baking By Peyton creates one-of-a-kind designs, so I won’t copy the cakes you send, but I’ll use them as inspiration to create something special just for you!

Step 2: Receive Your Invoice and Make a Deposit

Once your order form has been reviewed, you will receive a digital invoice with the total cost of your order.

A 50% deposit is required to confirm and secure your order date, which is due upon receipt of the invoice. The remaining balance is due one week prior to pickup.

If you have any questions about your order, feel free to reach out.

Step 3: Confirm and Arrange Pickup

Approximately one week before your cake pickup date, you will receive a confirmation email along with instructions to arrange the pickup. Baking By Peyton operates as a pickup-only business, with pickup times dependent on Peyton’s availability. Delivery is available for weddings and larger events/orders.